Important notice - We are aware of a scam where people are impersonating CMD Recruitment to offer jobs via WhatsApp & Telegram. This is a scam, CMD Recruitment will never contact new candidates via these methods. Any legitmate offer from CMD Recruitment would be made via a telephone call.

CMD Ident
Accountancy.
CMD Ident
Administration.
CMD Ident
Design.
CMD Ident
Defence.
CMD Ident
Engineering.
CMD Ident
Finance.
CMD Ident
HR.
CMD Ident
Industrial.
CMD Ident
IT.
CMD Ident
Marketing.
CMD Ident
Sales.
CMD Ident
Technical.

Leading Recruitment Agency in Wiltshire | CMD Recruitment

Discover your next job or find your ideal employee with CMD Recruitment, the largest and most established recruitment agency in Wiltshire and Bath.

Why Salary Benchmarking Is a Game-Changer in a Competitive Hiring Market

Why Salary Benchmarking Is a Game-Changer in a Competitive Hiring Market

July 31, 2025

Key Takeaways

Salary benchmarking helps employers stay competitive by comparing pay against the market, aligning offers with business realities, and using ongoing insights to attract and retain talent without overspending.

  • Review starting salaries regularly to stay ahead in a tight hiring market.
  • Use both quantitative data and qualitative context, not just headline numbers.
  • Factor in location, perks, and working patterns like shifts.
  • Track competitor changes and experience levels requested.
  • Balance competitive pay with sustainable operational costs.

When was the last time you reviewed your starting salaries? For many employers, the answer is much less recent than would be ideal. Failing to regularly review your starting salaries can put a company on the back foot, forcing them to respond to take a reactive rather than proactive stance.

If you regularly find that prospective hires will counter with a higher salary request, this isn’t just a sign that job hunters are more bold in their search. It could be a sign that you aren’t competitive in your sector.

Salary benchmarking will help to ensure you outpace your competitors and are able to secure the best talent. If you want to avoid losing good candidates to your competitors, it’s high time you start benchmarking starting salaries. In this guide, we’ll explore how this practice can help you to stay ahead while also outlining how to do it effectively.

What is salary benchmarking?

What is salary benchmarking?

Regularly reviewing your starting salaries against competitors in your sector is essential for staying competitive. 

This approach is not just useful for hiring in a candidate’s market, when there are more employers chasing fewer candidates. It’s also helpful when you are hiring in an employer’s market, when there are more candidates chasing fewer roles. 

In this instance, it can help you to avoid offering starting salaries that are too high, which could result in employees having to wait longer for their first pay review.

Salary benchmarking is all about looking at what other employers are offering for the same role. It can also compare salaries for different roles, but with a similar level of seniority and educational level. 

Finally, it’s also important to take into consideration the impact your staffing costs will have on operational costs. There’s little sense in looking to increase starting salaries if your current business operations won’t allow for this increase in spending.

Topic Key Point
What is salary benchmarking? Comparing roles and pay with the wider market to keep offers competitive and sustainable.
When to benchmark Continuously track salaries, not just when hiring, to avoid reactive decisions.
Market conditions Effective in both candidate and employer markets to prevent under- or over-paying.
Data inputs Use public sources, candidate feedback, counteroffers, and internal hire data.
Contextual factors Account for location, shifts, perks, and required experience.
Operational impact Ensure salary decisions align with budgets and broader business viability.
Strategic use Combine quantitative trends with qualitative signals to guide hiring strategy.

Why bother with salary benchmarking?

Why bother with salary benchmarking?

Benchmarking isn’t something that every company will bother with. Some companies look to internal forces to determine what they offer as starting salaries. This will typically coincide with a desire to keep staffing costs as low as possible in order to maximise profits.

In this scenario, employees know that their salaries are less than market value. And they know that penny pinching at the top is what keeps salaries this low. This isn’t what we would  describe as an employee-centric company.

Companies that take employee happiness and engagement seriously will be much more concerned with ensuring that salaries are both competitive and sustainable. After all, there’s little sense in joining a company for a high salary if their employee spending ultimately puts them out of business.

How to start salary benchmarking

How to start salary benchmarking

Wondering how to get started with salary benchmarking? Try these following tips:

  • Don’t think of salary benchmarking as something that you only do when you are ready to hire. It’s helpful to monitor salaries at all times, as this can help you to avoid losing strong employees to the competition.
  • You can use information available from public sources like LinkedIn, GlassDoor and Indeed to look at offered salaries and reported salaries for similar roles. When employees join from other companies, you can also use their reported salaries to fill in the gaps. And if a prospective hire is getting counter offers from another company, this information can also help you to see how high they are willing to go.
  • Remember to take things like location and additional perks into consideration. Working patterns can also influence the salary on offer, with shift work likely to command a higher salary.
  • Keep a record of salary changes across different competitors. This can also give you insight into their operations, as they might start to raise starting salaries if they are experiencing a period of sustained growth.
  • Make a note of the number of years of experience requested for each role. This can help you to make projections for more senior and less senior roles. 
  • Don’t just look at your direct competitors. Look at any company that is hiring from the same pool of candidates. This can help you to spot trends between sectors, not just for specific roles.

Stay Proactive

Track market pay continuously to anticipate shifts, refine offers, and protect retention—especially when competitors raise starting salaries or adjust experience requirements.

Think Beyond Numbers

Use qualitative signals—like counteroffers, sector trends, and candidate expectations—alongside salary data, and balance competitiveness with sustainable operating costs.

How to use benchmarking to stay ahead

You don’t always have to outpace the competition in terms of starting salaries – unless you need to hire the very best of the best. Salary benchmarking should help to inform your strategy, but there needs to be more insight than just numbers. Look for qualitative data alongside the quantitative.

Salary benchmarking is a great way to keep an eye on the competition and look for signs of issues in your sector. Stagnant salaries might indicate wider economic pressures that are impacting more than just your company. 

If you are facing a period of stagnancy, you can look for ways to support your employees in other ways, either through improved work/life balance or additional perks.

Staying competitive in today’s market starts with attracting the right talent at the right salary. Post your vacancy with CMD Recruitment and let our experts connect you with the best candidates.

Highlights

  • Candidate vs. employer market awareness
  • Continuous salary monitoring, not one-off
  • Public data sources (e.g., job boards, reports)
  • Location and perks adjustments
  • Experience bands and role seniority
  • Qualitative insights alongside numbers

FAQs

How often should we review our starting salaries?
Make benchmarking a continuous process. Regular checks help you stay competitive and avoid losing candidates or overpaying during market shifts.
What data should inform our benchmarks?
Blend public salary data, job ads, candidate and employee insights, counteroffers, and internal hiring outcomes for a balanced view.
How do we stay competitive without inflating costs?
Align pay with budgets and use total reward levers—location flexibility, shifts compensation, perks, and development—to add value beyond base salary.
Back to Blog