Important notice - We are aware of a scam where people are impersonating CMD Recruitment to offer jobs via WhatsApp & Telegram. This is a scam, CMD Recruitment will never contact new candidates via these methods. Any legitmate offer from CMD Recruitment would be made via a telephone call.

CMD Ident
Accountancy.
CMD Ident
Administration.
CMD Ident
Design.
CMD Ident
Defence.
CMD Ident
Engineering.
CMD Ident
Finance.
CMD Ident
HR.
CMD Ident
Industrial.
CMD Ident
IT.
CMD Ident
Marketing.
CMD Ident
Sales.
CMD Ident
Technical.

Leading Recruitment Agency in Wiltshire | CMD Recruitment

Discover your next job or find your ideal employee with CMD Recruitment, the largest and most established recruitment agency in Wiltshire and Bath.

What a Bad Hire Costs after January 2027

What a Bad Hire Costs after January 2027

November 17, 2026

Most employers have hired someone who didn’t work out. It’s frustrating and it’s expensive, but until now there has been time to put it right. For most new starters, you had up to two years before unfair dismissal protection applied.

From 1st January 2027, that changes. Here’s what a bad hire costs today, what’s different from January, and how to reduce the chances of it happening.

At a glance

A hire that doesn’t work out has always been costly. From January 2027, leaving the decision too long becomes costly as well.

The cost you can see

Salary, National Insurance and recruitment fees, often paid twice.

The cost you can’t

Management time, lost output and the effect on the rest of the team.

What changes in January

Protection after six months, and no cap on unfair dismissal compensation.

What does a bad hire cost?

Start with the costs you can calculate. Say you hire someone through an agency on a £30,000 salary, but they leave after five months and you need to find a replacement.

Cost
Amount
Salary paid over five months
£12,500
Employer’s National Insurance on that salary
About £1,560
Recruitment fee at 20% of salary
£6,000
Recruitment fee to replace them
£6,000
Total you can count
About £26,060

For illustration only. It assumes employer’s National Insurance at 15% above £5,000 a year and no rebate on the first fee. Your own figures will differ.

In this example, the employer has spent over £26,000 on salary, National Insurance and recruitment fees, only to find themselves back where they started with an empty position to fill. While the employee may have contributed useful work during those five months, the business still faces the cost and disruption of recruiting someone new.

And that’s before you account for the less obvious costs. Some agencies offer rebates if a placement ends early, so check your terms to see whether you’re covered. Even then, the costs that don’t appear on an invoice can quickly add up.

Costs you can count

  • Salary and National Insurance
  • Recruitment fees or advertising
  • Training courses and equipment
  • Agency cover while the role is empty

Costs that are harder to see

  • Hours of management time
  • Work that has to be redone
  • Customers who had a poor experience
  • Good people who leave because of it

What changes on 1 January 2027?

Two things, both under the Employment Rights Act 2025, and both apply where employment ends on or after 1 January 2027.

 

Now

Two years to decide

An employee generally needs two years’ service to claim ordinary unfair dismissal. Compensation is capped at a year’s pay or £123,543, whichever is lower.

 

1 January 2027

Six months to decide

The qualifying period drops to six months. Anyone who already has six months’ service is covered from that date.

 

1 January 2027

The cap is removed

The limit on the compensatory award for unfair dismissal is due to go, so awards will be based on what the person has lost.

These changes don’t stop you from ending someone’s employment if things aren’t working out. However, once unfair dismissal protection applies, you’ll generally need a fair reason and a fair process. Leaving problems unresolved for months could therefore become much more costly.

Why the first six months matter more now

Previously, employers had more time to address performance concerns before ordinary unfair dismissal protection applied. Some might have given a struggling employee another few months in the hope that things would improve.

From January, each month you wait brings you closer to the point where ending the employment becomes harder and carries more risk.

So the cost of a bad hire is no longer only what you spend. It’s also what you risk if the decision comes too late or is handled badly. The best way to reduce that risk is to hire the right person in the first place.

How to reduce the risk

Getting the right person through the door is only half the job. A good induction helps new starters understand what’s expected of them and gives them the support they need to settle in. Regular check-ins also give managers a chance to spot problems early and address them before they become bigger issues.

Before and after you hire

✓Agree a clear brief before you advertise
✓Ask every candidate the same core questions
✓Test the skills the job needs
✓Take up references before the start date
✓Set written objectives in week one
✓Book probation reviews in the diary from day one
✓Raise concerns early and in writing
✓Consider temp to perm for roles where fit is hard to judge

Don’t rush into the wrong hire

When a role has been empty for weeks, it’s tempting to offer it to the strongest candidate from a shortlist that doesn’t quite meet your needs. If nobody is right, it’s usually cheaper to keep looking, with temporary cover if you need it.

This article is a general guide and isn’t legal advice. If you’re unsure how the rules apply to your business, speak to an employment solicitor or your HR adviser.

How CMD Recruitment can help

We’ve been helping employers across Wiltshire and Bath find the right people since 2004. We take time to understand the role and your business before we start, and we speak to every candidate before you see their CV. If you’d like to try someone in the role before you commit, we can arrange that on a temporary basis too.

Want to get your next hire right?

Tell us about the role and we’ll help you find someone who fits.

Back to Blog